What Happens When the Market Crashes Shortly Before Retirement?

What Happens When the Market Crashes Shortly Before Retirement?

For good reason, one of the greatest concerns for individuals approaching retirement is the chance that the market may have a significant downturn immediately prior to retirement. Unlike younger investors who have decades for their investments to recover from losses, individuals approaching retirement have a shorter time horizon and may need to begin making withdrawals from their portfolio to support standard living expenses.

Although a market crash may not necessarily require retirement to be postponed, such an event can create challenges to be overcome. However, with a precautionary strategy as well as proper actions should the time arise, investors can potentially maintain their desired lifestyle with little to no stress throughout the process.

To educate readers, the following discussion explores appropriate investment allocation and withdrawals strategies.

The order in which market returns arrive, not only their average over time, is what makes this timing so consequential — a dynamic we explore further in Understanding Sequence of Returns Risk.

How Can You Reduce Risk Before Retirement?

Although equities act as a strong driver for portfolio growth, the volatility associated with them suggests that an investor should gradually shift a portion of this allocation towards investments that are less tied to stock market volatility. It may not be wise to expose oneself to a reasonable likelihood of substantial losses at an unfavorable time.

Investors should consider their investment time horizon, financial objectives, and tolerance for risk when determining an appropriate asset allocation. Several investment options may pose as portfolio volatility reducing candidates.

Money market funds and cash equivalents provide liquidity and relatively stable values; therefore, they are suitable for impending near-term expenses. Certificates of Deposit (CDs) may also be attractive because they offer predetermined interest rates along with principal protection when held to maturity.

However, CDs do come with early withdrawal penalties and the potential risk that inflation may outpace their rate of return. High-quality short-maturity bond funds are also worthy of consideration. Interest rates and market conditions can impact these funds, but to a smaller extent compared to traditional equity markets. In addition, equities themselves may serve a function in reducing risk—specifically blue chip, dividend paying stocks (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, n.d.)

There undoubtedly is a greater scope of low-risk investments than those previously mentioned, but they should not enter the scene in an attempt to eliminate stocks from a portfolio. Instead, investors should continuously maintain a balance between growth, income, and capital preservation. CFP Board (2025) recommends periodically rebalancing investments in order to maintain your investment mix at all stages in life.

One common, simple retirement planning strategy is to keep about one to three years of anticipated portfolio withdrawals in liquid, lower-risk assets. This can then serve as an extra-large emergency fund: to be utilized during market crashes and downturns. The appropriate reserve is arguably difficult to determine and is based upon the individual's spending requirements, guaranteed income sources, and make-up of the remainder of the portfolio.

Which Investments Should You Withdraw from During a Market Crash?

If the market declines drastically, the order in which investments are sold has potential to be impactful on the long-term sustainability of a retirement portfolio. Selling depressed equities to cover routine living expenses as a retiree is a last resort. One intriguing reason this is the case is the asymmetric recovery math involved. Suppose a stock drops by 30%.

In order to reach breakeven, it requires a 42.86% gain. Selling at the bottom results in a realized loss (not merely a paper loss) that locks in that loss and shrinks the capital base left to earn that rebound.

Rather than following the previous scenario, investors should consider drawing from investments that have maintained their value, namely the lower-risk investments aforementioned. This approach will give the stocks, for example, the time they need to fully recover and potentially return even greater multiples on the starting capital. The rule seems clear: hold what's down, sell what's up. Yet, what happens if nearly everything declines at the same time?

Unfortunately, even fully proper diversification does not guarantee that every investment will maintain its value or appreciate. Even bonds can experience losses, and eventually one's money market accounts can be depleted. In these dire circumstances, an investor must choose between the lesser of evils.

He must evaluate which holdings have experienced the smallest losses and use those investments to fund necessary distributions.

How Do Taxes Affect Which Account You Draw From?

Tax considerations are substantially important as well. It must be noted that selling investments in a taxable brokerage account is very different from withdrawing from a traditional IRA or Roth IRA.

For example, withdrawals from non-qualified brokerage accounts generally have only the gains portion subjected to preferential capital gains rates, qualified withdrawals from a traditional IRA are wholly taxed as ordinary income, and qualified withdrawals from a Roth IRA are generally tax-free.

Should You Postpone Retirement?

In cases where circumstances are dire, it can make financial sense to postpone retirement. Doing so can allow investments the opportunity to recover from market losses. Also, the number of years an individual must rely on market savings reduces, which means a smaller portfolio is required. Lastly, continuing to work can allow one to make additional contributions to retirement accounts and possibly increase their social security benefits.

According to the Social Security Administration (SSA, n.d.), individuals who delay claiming benefits beyond their full retirement age generally receive delayed retirement credits that can increase benefits by about 6.5-8% annually for each year they delay claiming, up to age 70.

Luckily, postponing retirement is not always necessary. To make ends meet, individuals can ensure they meet modest spending requirements, draw from an available pension, or draw from another reliable income source, such as an entertaining part time job. Before deciding to postpone retirement, a full analysis of one's financial picture should ideally be performed, from less obvious factors like health and goals to financial risk capacity and spending habits.

What Does a Complete Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Look Like?

One commonly discussed approach to annual withdrawals during retirement is the 4% rule. However, this rule of thumb does not assume the tail-end data point of a market crash leading into retirement to be the case study at hand. Morningstar's (2025) retirement income research estimated a 3.9% starting withdrawal rate to be a more accurate base case.

The true withdrawal rate in this most unfortunate, extreme of circumstances unequivocally has the potential to be an even lower percent. The employment of a financial advisor can help provide the average investor with a more accurate estimate for their specific case while accounting for risk tolerance, for example desired likelihood of success.

Ultimately, a comprehensive retirement withdrawal strategy may include all of the following. At the outset, an investor should maintain sufficient cash reserves or other lower-risk stable assets or investments. Next, the use of Social Security, pensions, and other predictable income sources should be appropriately employed.

Discretionary spending should then be adjusted, if necessary, when investment performance is unfavorable. Also, during these moments as well as regularly, rebalancing of investments can be done to ensure desired asset allocation is maintained. Throughout this period, withdrawals from taxable brokerage, traditional retirement accounts, and Roth accounts should always be considered from a tax-optimized view. Periodically, portfolio balances should be reviewed and whether current retirement spending is sustainable should be investigated.

Key Takeaways

  • Investors should consider their investment time horizon, financial objectives, and tolerance for risk when determining an appropriate asset allocation.
  • One simple retirement planning strategy is to keep about one to three years of anticipated portfolio withdrawals in liquid, lower-risk assets.
  • The 4% withdrawal rule of thumb does not assume the tail-end data point of a market crash leading into retirement to be the case study at hand.
  • A market crash shortly before retirement can surely be unsettling. However, it does not have to result in abandoning retirement hopes and dreams.

Facing a Downturn Before Retirement with a Plan

A market crash shortly before retirement can surely be unsettling. However, it does not have to result in abandoning retirement hopes and dreams. Maintaining adequate lower-risk investments and following research-backed methods can mitigate the likelihood of such an event robbing an investor of such a well-deserved life transition. Should there seem to be the need to take extra precaution, verification with an advisor and consideration of other, viable means may be beneficial.

Have Questions About Managing Your Portfolio?

If you have questions about your investment portfolio, your retirement planning, or would like to discuss whether your current strategy aligns with your long-term goals, please give our office a call at (586) 226-2100. Please feel free to forward this article to a friend, family member, or colleague who might benefit from thinking about their portfolio in a new way.

We hope you learned something today. If you have any feedback or suggestions, we would love to hear them.

Best Regards,

Daniel A. Ladzinski, M.S., CFP®, CRPC®, AWMA®, MPAS™

with contributions by Robert L. Wink, Kenneth R. Wink, James D. Wink, Zachary A. Bachner, CFP® and James C. Baldwin

Daniel Ladzinski
About the Author

Daniel A. Ladzinski, M.S., CFP®, CRPC®, AWMA®, MPAS™

Advisor | Client Services, Summit Financial Consulting, LLC

A financial advisor at Summit Financial Consulting, Daniel graduated summa cum laude from Hillsdale College with a B.S. in Financial Management and Applied Mathematics in 2024. He has obtained several licenses, including the Series 7, Series 63, Series 65, Variable Life and Annuity Contracts, as well as Life, Health & Accident Insurance. Daniel has experience in several wealth management companies in the surrounding area. Each of these positions helped solidify his desire to serve clients and utilize his background in mathematics to pursue optimal financial plans. During his time in college, Daniel honed his analytical skills through active participation in the Hillsdale College Applied Mathematics Club. His strong interest in personal investing led him to develop specialized watchlists, alerts, and strategies, demonstrating his ability to create data-driven solutions. Among his many hobbies, Daniel is an avid multi-instrumentalist. He led the Hillsdale College Big Band on the saxophone, and he is currently delving into the music community of metro Detroit. He is also passionate about soccer, volleyball, disc golf, botany, numismatics, and, most importantly, his Catholic faith, family, and friends.

More about Daniel →